The holidays often mean more time with spouses, partners, former partners, and extended family. They can also lead to stressful situations in which an argument escalates, and law enforcement becomes involved.
If you are arrested for domestic violence in Florida after a holiday argument, one of your first questions after being released may be: Can I go back home?
The answer depends on the orders entered in your case. A domestic violence arrest can affect where you live, who you can contact, and, in some circumstances, your ability to possess firearms or ammunition. Understanding those restrictions is important because violating them can lead to additional criminal charges.
Can You Go Home After a Domestic Violence Arrest in Florida?
An arrest does not necessarily mean you permanently lose the right to return to your residence. However, a judge may impose conditions that prevent you from returning home while the criminal case is pending.
Florida courts can impose no-contact conditions that prohibit contact with the alleged victim. Depending on the circumstances, an order may also require you to maintain a separate residence.
This can create difficult situations when the accused and alleged victim share a home, children, pets, vehicles, finances, or other responsibilities.
The fact that your name is on the lease, mortgage, or deed does not necessarily allow you to disregard a court order restricting access to the residence.
What Does a No-Contact Order Mean?
A no-contact order can restrict direct and indirect communication with the alleged victim. Depending on the terms of the order, prohibited contact may include phone calls, text messages, social media messages, emails, in-person conversations, or messages delivered through another person.
One particularly important point is that the alleged victim generally cannot simply give you permission to ignore the court’s order.
Even if both parties want to communicate or reconcile after the argument, the defendant remains responsible for complying with the restrictions imposed by the court unless they are modified.
Can a No-Contact or Separate-Residence Order Be Changed?
In some circumstances, a defense attorney may ask the court to modify the conditions of release.
Whether modification is appropriate depends on the facts of the case and the court’s decision. Until a judge changes an existing order, however, the defendant should continue following it.
Returning home or contacting the alleged victim before receiving permission from the court can create another legal problem on top of the original domestic violence charge.
Can a Domestic Violence Case Affect Your Firearm Rights?
For gun owners, a domestic violence case can raise another set of serious concerns.
The effect on firearm possession depends on what orders have been entered and how the case proceeds. For example, Florida law prohibits a person who is subject to a qualifying final domestic violence injunction from having a firearm or ammunition in their care, custody, possession, or control.
A violation of that prohibition can result in a separate first-degree misdemeanor. Florida law also provides for firearm and ammunition surrender when ordered by the court in connection with a domestic violence injunction.
These restrictions make it important to understand exactly what an order says before handling, retrieving, transferring, or otherwise exercising control over firearms or ammunition.
What If Your Firearms Are Still Inside the Home?
This situation can become especially complicated when someone is prohibited from returning to a shared residence and their firearms are still inside.
Simply going back to retrieve a firearm could conflict with a separate residence or no-contact order. At the same time, a court order concerning firearms may impose specific requirements for surrendering firearms and ammunition, or otherwise addressing their possession.
Do not assume that owning the firearm gives you permission to retrieve it in violation of another court order. The specific language of every applicable order should be carefully reviewed.
Why Domestic Violence and Firearm Allegations Require Careful Attention
A domestic violence arrest can quickly become more complicated than the original allegation. There may be a criminal charge, restrictions on returning home, a no-contact order, an injunction proceeding, and potential firearm consequences happening at the same time.
Each proceeding can raise different legal questions. The circumstances of the arrest, statements from witnesses, body camera footage, 911 recordings, physical evidence, and the specific language of any court orders may all become important.
Katz & Phillips represents clients facing domestic violence and firearm-related charges throughout Orlando and Florida. If an arrest has affected your home, your ability to contact a family member, or your firearm rights, our attorneys can review the charges and court orders involved and help you understand your legal options.